Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Compassion, Forgiveness, And Other Random Emotions


I have no idea why and I don't remember the exact circumstance but I do know that in Cozumel I had a fleeting thought about my stepfather. And if you're new to my world and want to know about my stepfather, just go over there to that list of topics and click on a few of the childhood sexual abuse posts.

It wasn't odd that I thought about my stepfather, because I do think about him now and then and it's never in a good way. It's usually in a he's-a-monster-and-almost-ruined-my-life-and-I-hate-him way. But this quick thought, almost like a dart to the brain whispered something about forgiveness.

Now listen here- I believe there are two things that a survivor of sexual abuse is not required to do and those two things are to confront and to forgive. I am sorry but I am not Jesus and I am not Mother Theresa and I am not even a Buddhist or a Christian and not even a good damn Pagan. I am nothing but a member of the Church of Bat-Shit Crazy and that's that.
So when I had that dart-to-the-brain, that out of nowhere fleeting thought of my stepfather with the idea of forgiveness in the thought somewhere, I dismissed it. Okay, I examined it and said, "Where the fuck did that come from?" and then I dismissed it. I was under the influence, folks. The influence of gentle Mayan ways and being in a place I adore with the man I adore and living a life that I could never even imagine having the vast fortune to hope for, much less live.

And then the other night, my brother called. The only brother out of three who is in any way in touch with this man, his father. One of my brothers has changed his last name, in fact. I mean- that's a statement. But I asked my brother who called if his father was still alive. And if it was, in fact true, that he has Alzheimer's.

"Yes," my brother said. "He's alive and he does." He told me that the old man had called him a few weeks ago and asked him to take him up to check on his mother who has been dead for thirty or so years and who was one of the meanest, nastiest harridans ever put on this planet. She was quite literally insane and not in a good way. But she's dead and he didn't remember that and he felt the need to go check on her.

And when my brother told me this, my first thought was, "Oh. Poor thing."

WHAT???!!!

What was I thinking? Poor thing? Now where in hell did that come from?

And truthfully, I don't know.

But the fact remains, it's so sad and so pitiful that it can't help but move me somehow. And I think that even six months ago it would have moved me to think, "Good. Maybe he's at the end stages. Maybe he's suffering."

And part of me still can't wait for that man, that soul, to be gone from this earth where I live. And part of me is completely unaffected that he may be suffering. I mean- the suffering he's caused others will never be attenuated in this lifetime. Never.

But part of me, some soft part of me which realizes that I have survived and that I have felt joy in this life, unbelievably, and that I have managed to create a life and a family of great beauty in many ways, knows that he never did and that he never will and that his suffering does not help me at all and that I can feel sorry for him.

Oh. I hate typing those words. I hate thinking those words.
But I do. I feel sorry for him.

My yoga teacher and I talked all through class today. It was one of those classes where it was just two of us, and one of her children is going through some really, really hard times right now which is causing her intense pain and worry and anxiety. She and I are as different as night and day but we are both women who love our children above all else and there, and on the yoga mats, we can meet. We shared some things and we talked about what the bottom line message of Christ was. She said that to her it was love and forgiveness. I said that for me, forgiveness implies a god who needs to forgive us and sins, too, and I don't buy into that whole thing but I believe in love and compassion. She said that she thinks that compassion and forgiveness may be the same, and I understood what she was saying, but I don't buy that one either. I'm not sure what I think about forgiveness but I'm pretty sure I don't have the power to forgive. And what does that mean? If I say I forgive someone, does that take anything away? No. But if I say that we are all extremely flawed individuals (as Jimmy Buffet, the beach bard says) and we make mistakes and if someone has done something that has hurt me and I can love them anyway, unconditionally and without any breath or hint of the martyr, then that is compassion and that is what I hope to achieve.

I will, quite honestly, never be able to do that for my stepfather. I can get to the part where I understand that he was extremely flawed but it pretty much stops there. Hurting a child goes beyond my definition of understanding.

But. But.

But. I do feel sorry for him even though he has caused so much suffering in his flawed, fucked-up life. The Buddhists say that life is suffering and that to understand that and to try to relieve others of their suffering is the meaning of it all.
That's pretty harsh and really, really hard.

But it's sort of beautiful.

And do you see that picture? That's my child. My very own child, pregnant with her very own child and this is where my life is. How can I not feel so full of the blessing this path has lead me to that I can't feel some compassion for that man's suffering? He didn't ruin my life. He could have, but somehow, by some miracle, he didn't manage to. I am not dead, I am not completely insane (just bat-shit crazy) and I have so much love in my life that my cup does overflow.

Baby steps. It's all about baby steps. And quick darts to the brain and yes, heart, and deep searching and change.

And a lot of other stuff I don't even pretend to understand.

But that's what I'm thinking about today. And it feels...good.

22 comments:

  1. You know, a friend of mine was telling me that she would pray for the motherfucker who abused Hannah. Because, you know, that's what we are supposed to do, right? And she was very compassionate to me in saying, "I am just going to go on ahead and pray for him FOR you, because I know you don't want to and I know you can't and you might never want or be able to." And even though I hate him, even though the rage is so deep and tearing a hole in my gut at times, well, I was glad that somebody is praying for him, and that it doesn't have to be me.

    Which has nothing to do with your post, yet has everything to do with it. Because....even including pain and abuse and entrance into the gates of insanity on occasion, we have been given so much. We have been given so much joy that it makes us cry (like your birthday) and so much beauty and so muck love as to hurt with the lovely weight of it, and they have nothing. How can one NOT feel compassion for that?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Listen- I am not praying for any motherfucking abusers. No. But it interests me to no end that suddenly I have this tiny flame of compassion for this particular man after a lifetime of honestly not having one molecule of it.
    And you are right in what you said and yes, that is what my post was about. And how suddenly things can change in hearts. At least a very tiny amount.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a beautiful person you are, and this post is beautiful, too.

    Now the really serious part: can I join the Church of the Bat-Shit Crazy?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Elizabeth- I feel you may already be a member.

    ReplyDelete
  5. i can't imagine ever ever ever praying for someone who has abused a child. i also can't imagine forgiving such a heinous crime.

    i do however feel that there is something to the compassion part.

    there is a whole lot of suffering in life, and probably someone would have to suffer a TON before they could injure a precious wee child, and so then where did the abuse start and where do we draw the lines telling us what's okay or forgivable or whatever?

    we are all part of this enormous spectrum of damage and healing and it seems to me that if we do not have compassion for everyone, then we cannot have it for anyone.

    but what, prey tell, do i know anyway? i am a bug.

    wv='militi'

    as in HUE-militi

    ReplyDelete
  6. Forgiveness is a Christian concept that I don't go along with for the same reasons you mentioned. What I TRY to do with situations is not let the hate fuck up my life and to move on if I can. It always takes a long time. I can understand your bouts of compassion for your asshole stepfather as a person but not as a perpetrator. Karma doesn't happen fast enough for me with some people.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ms. Moon. It must be the whole "re-evalating" thing that happens to all of us when we have children. The innocence of a child triggers in most as reflective atmosphere where we get a different perspective on our parents & our upbringing. My guess is that your new "dart" was in some way connected to that b/c your daughter is bringing a very beautiful baby into this world, into Your world and you know the love and protection that little one deserves and is going to experience. Hugs to you!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yo, I didn't say I was praying for him, nor that I forgive him; don't, can't, won't. Just to clarify that here.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Kori- Oh. I totally got what you meant. Totally.

    Adrienne- I completely agree but I doubt seriously I will ever have compassion for everyone. I wish I could but there's part of me which will probably never get there.
    But here's another thing- I think having compassion for others in very difficult situations makes us more compassionate with our own
    imperfect selves.

    Joy- Karma. Another concept I don't really understand. Except that yes, if you give out hate, hate will definitely come back to you. That I am sure of.

    Mel- I hope so. I know that I didn't really begin to get angry about the abuse I had suffered until my children were the age I was when I was abused. Our children ARE our teachers.

    Xbox- This is not a feeling I came to through wanting to or trying to at all. I had no need. And it's not a huge feeling, believe me. A whisper.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Child survivors are some of the most enduring and thoughtful people on the planet I think.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I think it may just be about you being a better person. That's perhaps the curse of having understanding and nuance and not thinking the world is always black and white. Even though he doesn't deserve it, you are open to seeing even his hurt.

    Is that too woolly? I kind of get what I mean.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It really is difficult to reconcile those feelings and try to put ANY emotion other than bitter, angry feelings toward your abuser (no matter the type of abuse endured). I struggle with this as well.

    Someday, I think we should all congregate for a church service for the batshit crazy ;) I will bring the beer.

    ReplyDelete
  13. yes ms moon. i think if there is any truth to my ramblings, it is just that; if i can soften my glance toward others, perhaps i will soften my inward glance as well.

    i love you and respect you so.

    thank you for sharing these intimate parts of your experience.

    xoxoxo

    ReplyDelete
  14. Marsha- Wow. That's a whole other perspective. Thank-you for giving us that.

    Mwa- I kind of get it too.

    SJ- Sounds great to me. I'll provide the hummus and tour of the chicken coop.

    Cat- Thank-you so much.

    Adrienne- Always. You are always so thoughtful and loving in your words. And have I told you how much I love that new picture? I do.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Good for you M Moon.

    I found that while I was preg wtih Harley and the first years of his life, I was starting to remember mixed things about some family members and a lot of stuff "surfaced". Somehow babies can do that. I wonder if having a grandchild has anything to do with the compassion arrows? Interesting.

    Whatever it is, it sounds odd and good at the same time. I call it a subtle shift.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I had a whole thing written on here on what I think about forgiveness, etc...And, then I erased it all. That's because it really it doesn't matter. What I find is the important thing to take away from your writing today is that it's amazing you have any kind of compassion for that man who hurt you so badly. Just amazing.

    ReplyDelete
  17. A lot to think about, Ms. Moon. Forgiveness is a hard concept for me to wrap my brain around...
    I'm better with compassion. I don't think they are the same thing at all. Maybe they overlap some...
    hmmm

    ReplyDelete
  18. I'm am glad you feel the way you do. I am happy for you.

    I'll still hate the guy if you don't mind though.

    Love,

    SB

    ReplyDelete
  19. This can only be a good thing.

    And tht is a beautiful picture.

    ReplyDelete

Tell me, sweeties. Tell me what you think.