Wednesday, April 17, 2013

What Purpose Does All This Serve?

Here is a confession: I have not watched any of the videos or the images from the explosions in Boston. Nor do I plan to. I cannot, for the life of me, figure out what purpose that would serve.
And yet, I feel that people all over the world are obsessively doing just that. Going back to those sites over and over again to watch the horror, the smoke, the blood, the screaming.
See? I can imagine it. And that is as much as I want to do. That is more than I want to do.

As I walked this morning, I took note of where the most blooming blackberries are clustered. I think this is what the human brain is wired to do. To take note of that which can be of potential importance in our own lives and to register and store it until the information is needed. This is true for potential dangers as well. The day I saw a bear track in the dirt road, the hair on the back of my neck stood up, my heart began beating faster and I suddenly became hyper-aware of my surroundings. This was understandable and it could have, if the bears around here were actual killers of humans, which they are not, been a life-saver.
This is the cave-man brain. This is the brain which has sustained the species. The brain that remembers where the fruiting bushes are, the brain which remembers where the bear crosses the path. The brain which can observe that which works and help us to adapt our behavior appropriately and to observe that which does not.

But we are so far removed from the needs which the brain evolved for. Very few of us will need to know where the berries are to ensure the survival of our family or our tribe. Very few of us will need to know where the bear crosses. But our brains, our amazing brains, still have the need to observe and note and store information and the amount of information which it encounters daily has multiplied geometrically to the point where no human brain on this earth can contain it or even receive it and so we have invented these machines which do that for us and those machines deliver even more information to the brain and quite frankly, I believe that this is part of why so many of us are constantly depressed and overwhelmed and anxious.

If we watch images of horror which happened somewhere else in this world, our cave-man brains want desperately to store and DO SOMETHING with that information. But what on earth can we actually do? I sit here in Florida and I can mourn the loss of those who died, I can grieve for those whose injuries will cause them great pain and suffering for a lifetime and for their families. But does that really serve any purpose? Will it help those who are dead? Will it help those who are suffering?

I don't think so.

And will I be any more apt to be careful in crowded places? Now there, perhaps, possibly. But what good will that do? Was there not more security at the finish line of that race than any of us can imagine? Were there not more cameras in one place than at any other place on earth at that moment?
This is the thing about random, senseless violence. Because it is random, because it is senseless (to those of us who are sane, at least) there is no way to predict it and despite all efforts, no way to entirely remove the possibility of it.

I don't think that evil, insane acts of horror are on the rise in the world. I believe that history would bear me out on this. But because we have access to every report, every video of such violence, we feel that there is the possibility for it everywhere. This is not unlike the fact that a child's abduction in a town all the way across the country makes us feel as if it had happened in our own backyard, thus causing us to restrict our children's activities in a way that will quite definitely have a negative impact on their lives. This is why I don't read the postings on Facebook about missing children. So many of them have been abducted by family members or have run away because of something horrible going on in a family that it seems to me that more purpose would be served by all of us paying attention to what is going on in our own neighborhoods and schools and families and churches. I am a living example of the fact that most sexual molestation of children occurs in the home by family members. It is almost always a known and trusted person who is the one doing the molestation and these perpetrators are so very skillful at finding the very child who is most needy for adult attention and love to groom and then molest. Of course there are the rare instances where a deranged person unknown to the community darts in and kidnaps a child but this, I believe, is not the common occurrence that we feel it might be because of the media.

We read about these things. We see the videos. Our brains register them as danger to us and to our children. But there is nothing we can do about any of it and so we are left with a lingering and persistent anxiety and fear which escalates into a sort of national paranoia and even insanity.

Look. I'm not saying that we should not be aware of what is going on in the world. Trust me- there is no way to avoid it. But what good does it do for us to obsessively watch the videos, to endlessly listen to the reports on radio or to read the Tweets about the event or to watch the TV news coverage? I think it becomes a sort of sick voyeurism after a certain point.

Maybe I'm just crazy but if I see one more repost of the picture of that precious little boy who was killed in the explosions, I think I'm going to scream. Some of the postings ask for prayers for him and his family but I don't have any religious belief that any prayer I might offer up can do one damn thing for his soul or his suffering family. Again, that's just me. But viewed in this light, what can seeing his picture do but kill a little part of my own soul?

I am still living. So are you. All we can do in the wake of such events is to continue to be one of the many, indeed the majority, of human beings who base their lives not on hate or violence but on love and compassion and caring. Seeing blood and smoke and horror does not foment those emotions in me. It only makes me feel useless and inadequate and horrified and paralyzed and that is not going to help a thing.

And so no, I am not going to watch those videos. I am not going to listen to the news obsessively where even on NPR there are people calling in with ridiculous baseless assumptions, with paranoid theories, with their fears and their anxieties and a sort of pain which quite honestly, is not theirs to feel but which has been thrust upon them by the images which have made them feel as if they were there when it happened. Yes, there is the belief that we are all related, that everyone's suffering is my own, but in reality, neither I nor anyone else can contain it all. That may have been possible when "everyone" was our tribe or our small village but our caveman brains cannot cope with the suffering and pain and horror of the entire world which is now available for us to know.

I've spent too many hours trying to say here what I wanted to say and I haven't gotten it right but more words aren't going to get that job done. Not my words, anyway.

Look- let's love each other. Let's do the best jobs we can with our own families, our own loved ones, our own lives. Let us acknowledge others' pain but let us not try to take on burdens which are not ours to take and which serve no purpose but to weigh us down in ways that prevent our ability to do the best we can for our own. And let us give some privacy to those who are actually and in real life, going through what they are going through.
Is that so crazy?
My cave-woman brain tells me it is the only way I can be. And in this instance, I am trusting it.



19 comments:

  1. Amen, Ms. Moon.
    We need to get our hands out of the pot, our faces off Facebook and be present in our own lives. I bet we all know someone who needs us right now. And that's where we can do good.
    xo

    ReplyDelete
  2. I could not have said it better. Much love to you, Ms. Moon. xo

    ReplyDelete
  3. You just got your daughter married. There is such joy in the air around you. Live in that place. Do not let deranged acts playing out in another place taint the sweetness of that. We can all do more good in the world by shedding light where we are. I so agree with you. xo

    ReplyDelete
  4. I could not agree more. I have not watched a single news cast nor read a single article, blog post, or opinion of what might have happened or how dreadful it was, etc. I'm not looking at the pictures. When they catch the person, I might read to see who and why but that is it. Because you know why? For all the reasons you listed. And I agree that the incidences of whatever has not increased one iota since I was a kid. It's just that we hear about every single instance no matter where in the world it happened whereas before, we didn't, couldn't possibly know about it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Amen. I wish I could say I have not looked at these images and videos and articles, but I have and that is probably the reason for my depressed and anxious state the past couple of days.

    Life was much happier, come to think of it, living off the grid with no TV. Believe me, I didn't miss it one bit and I was not at all curious what was going on in the world beyond my yard and my village.

    -invisigal

    ReplyDelete
  6. I swear it is like you just read my mind! Excellent post. This just reminds me and confirms why I have no TV in my house.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm just swimming around in the deep blue sea here but came up for a gulp of air, and am on my way back down. I'm not sure about the caveman brain part, but I agree with you about the ceaseless media coverage and the constant stream of "information" influencing people to be more voyeurs than anything else. I am curious, though, why this impulse to voyeurism even exists -- I find it fascinating, actually. Given that I watch my daughter have a gigantic seizure at least once a day, and I feel the accompanying adrenaline from doing so, it's curious to me how and why these isolated events become so ENORMOUS in the country's psyche. But I'm babbling now and hijacking your blog.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with a lot of what you had to say here. The news media is out of control and the constant replaying of the images and videos of carnage serve to make us depressed and in my opinion, to give other deranged people ideas. I often ask myself how I can help make the world a better place. Perhaps it is a lot easier for people like you with children to see the answer in your immediate vicinity as being your most important focus and I do believe you and those who visit your blog and who do have kids are doing a tremendous (tremendous) job of raising decent, loving, compassionate human beings who are our future. I also believe that the way each of us lives our lives and treats other people is vital to making a better, more peaceful world. That is my brand of religion. But there is something in me that does not believe we should ignore what is happening in the world -- and that is different than trying to change other cultures that are unlike our own. I also believe in collective energy and while I have no idea how that really works, when a mass of people send energy out into the universe towards people who are suffering it can't hurt. What is the difference between those of us who visit your blog sending you good and loving energy when you are having a hard time or facing a stressful event and us sending energy to those in Boston who have suffered from this tragedy, even if we don't know them personally? I might not have gotten your whole message right and if so, please set me straight. Sweet Jo

    ReplyDelete
  9. Rachel- I think so too. I do.

    Birdie- Thank you.

    Angella- That is it- what good does it do for us to bring darkness to our own place from far away if it does no good?

    Ellen Abbott- And it's not the Big Things we all know about intimately now. It's every small thing and if there can be justice brought about by this knowledge, it is a good thing. But so often, that is not the case.

    Invisigal- It is amazing how quickly we pull in our boundaries and are content with them if need be.

    Kelly M- Well, I do have TV but I find that it's the internet where most of the images come from these days. And am I ready to give that up? No.
    But I can pick and choose.

    Elizabeth- I think that you've hit on something here. Adrenaline rushes ARE powerful and I think there is an element of getting off on them for some people especially if the rush is not really accompanied by a threat to themselves or their own loved ones. And although you did not hijack my blog, you most certainly can any time you want.

    Sweet Jo- I agree- we should NOT ignore what is going on in the world. I just don't believe that we can take all in or take it all on or that we should. I don't know what I think about collective energy. I am not convinced either that it exists or that it does not. I think that when we, as a blog community, give each other support with words, that support, those words, are at least coming from a place of knowing each other to some degree. Perhaps not in the "meat world" as Dear Radish King says but in a very real way. If you say to me, "I know this is stressful for you because I know how you are but I also know that soon you will get through this situation and you will feel better because that is also how you are," then you are coming from a place of true understanding and knowledge and I will listen and be reminded and appreciate that. But for someone to just send good energy is a bit too much like magic for me. Now don't get me wrong- I believe in magic! But it is the sort of magic which comes from love, from hard work, from being aware of that which goes on around us in the natural world, from collective effort. But, my Very Sweet Jo, if you feel that sending energy to those in Boston is a true and valid thing to do, I trust you on that. Perhaps I just don't have the key to it. I don't know. As I so very, very often say, I do not know shit and I will stick to that! And one more thing- I really appreciate you saying what you believe and cherish you the more for it. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I wish you had your own talk show. I would watch it.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I grieve. I mourn. And like you, I have not watched the video's nor have I turned on the TV. My heart and my imagination tell me enough. We are two wise old grandmothers, I say.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I agree that it is ABSOLUTELY an adrenaline rush. I wish I had more insight here, but I am so tired. I am already so tired of the news coverage, which makes me feel like a cranky old bitch who doesn't give a shit. Of course, I do, but I seriously can't handle hearing about one thing OVER and OVER.

    ReplyDelete
  13. amen sister...i too will not watch and look at every graffic image out there, it is un-needed as my imagination does quite the job.....
    also wanted to say that you were so kind to those two mormon boys, and you should be proud as you showed by example what you meant with what you told them, right on! also you will be pleased to hear i have 4 crocus in my yard and the coltsfoot are also out along the road, yay!
    love from vermont

    ReplyDelete
  14. It's kind of like the thunderstorm going on here tonight.
    The weather guys have totally taken over the airways with their high-pitched staccato "coverage." Going on 5 hours now. There's a maybe tornado here and another up the road with tennis ball hail, and the City has set off the sirens while the weather stations claim the City is mistaken, and no one knows the truth the night holds for them in a land where weather tragedies are all too common. and so it goes out here on the plains.
    Our lives have become one big messy media event and imho the world has indeed gone mad.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I am fortunate that I live in Canada but we are still inundated with the news in the US. After 9/11, I had to start limiting my immersion in the media because it was giving me the worst anxiety. I've avoided this whole Boston bombing as much as possible. I used to work for this guy many years ago and today I found out his daughter ran in the marathon and finished a half hour before the first bomb went off. I'm just grateful she was fast.

    Boundaries. They're good. And you? Make more sense than warm socks on a cold day! Big hugs to you!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Even as a former journalist, I think you're correct. As I've said before, I am no friend of the 24-hour news cycle. We were better off when we had writers, editors and producers with time to consider the news before the next print cycle or broadcast, rather than filling a constant stream of airtime with endless speculation and talking heads and loops of the same witness videos over and over again.

    It is important to stay informed. But much of our current journalism doesn't inform. It actually MISinforms, as the rush to produce the next Tweet leads to the dispersal of incorrect information.

    I read the paper each morning (online -- I'm not THAT much of a Luddite) and on the days when there's been a big event I'll watch the news. But I do regulate my intake. I'd go crazy otherwise -- as you said, my inner Cave Man brain would see danger around every corner.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I have watched some of it but the constant replaying of the man falling with smoke in the background is old. And seeing that little boy over and over is enough. I suppose it is like rubber necking with a train or car wreck. After a while my neck gets sore and my eyes have seen enough. Time to realize that these acts happen all over the world on a regular basis. They just have reached us and we freak out as if this is something that cannot happen here. Well, it is happening. We are not immune to evil. We have helped perpetrate it around the world through our incessant quest for oil.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I have never responded to any blog post by anybody (and I read quite a few). When I read this though it was exactly the way I have been feeling about this event. And I work in Boston, not far from where it occurred. I know people who were there in a volunteer capacity at the finish line tents or running in the marathon itself. You are the first person I have seen to put this into words. Thank you for clarifying what I have been thinking and feeling. I stumbled on your blog from another; I'll be back I think.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous- Well, if this is the first time you have ever commented on a blog then surely you should get an answer. So I will tell you "thank-you" because I do very much appreciate your taking time to stop and tell me what you think and for reading here in the first place. Please feel free to come back any time whether you decide to comment again or not.

    ReplyDelete

Tell me, sweeties. Tell me what you think.